A Washington sentencing court can enter a no-contact order with children who are the defendant's own, but the order must survive a constitutional test that the judge has to apply on the record. On October 13, 2026, Division Two of the Court of Appeals reversed a five-year order barring a father from contacting his two daughters because the sentencing judge never addressed his right to parent.
Before restricting contact between a defendant and their child, the court must consider the constitutional right to parent, explain why the restriction is necessary, and ask whether a less restrictive option would protect the child. In State v. Mitchell, every conviction stood, including attempted first-degree murder, and only the order covering the children went back for that analysis.
At Blair Kim Moeller, our Seattle attorneys defend domestic violence charges for parents whose criminal case and family case are moving at the same time, so that an order entered in one case reaches into the other.
What a Crime-Related Prohibition Is
A crime-related prohibition is a court order barring conduct that directly relates to the circumstances of the crime the person was convicted of. That definition comes from RCW 9.94A.030(10), and RCW 9.94A.505(9) lets a court impose one as part of a felony sentence. A no-contact order entered at sentencing is the most common example.
Courts review these conditions with more care when they touch a constitutional right. Parents have a fundamental right to the care, custody, and companionship of their children. The Washington Supreme Court held in State v. Warren (2008) that a condition limiting that right may be upheld only if it is reasonably necessary to meet the essential needs of the State and public order, and it must be imposed with sensitivity.
The Court of Appeals applied that standard in State v. Reedy (2023), which sets out the steps. Before ordering no contact with a defendant's child, the sentencing court must, on the record, consider the right to parent, explain why the order is necessary, and explore whether viable less restrictive alternatives exist. A detailed explanation can be skipped only where the record already plainly shows the order is necessary.
What Happened at the Sentencing in Mitchell
During a divorce, Mitchell fired a handgun at his estranged wife's door and bedroom window while she and their two young daughters were inside. A jury convicted him of attempted first-degree murder, attempted first-degree burglary, and two counts of reckless endangerment involving the children, and he was sentenced to 307 months.
The State asked for a five-year order barring contact with the girls. The mother's victim impact statement described the harm to the children and also said how much they missed their father. Defense counsel asked the court not to enter the order or, at minimum, to allow written letters passed through a third party. The judge entered the full order, citing the children's psychological welfare, and told Mitchell he could not answer letters the children sent him.
Division Two held that skipping the balancing was error. The court said that on remand the judge might allow some limited contact or might not, and that the outcome was the trial court's call. What the trial court could not do was enter the order without weighing the right to parent on the record. The opinion is unpublished, but the rule it applies comes from published decisions, including the Supreme Court's in Warren.
A parent facing sentencing on a domestic violence charge is often more worried about the children than about the prison term. If that is your situation, call us at (206) 622-6562 and we will set up a consultation.
How a Criminal No-Contact Order Reaches the Parenting Plan
A criminal no-contact order and a parenting plan come from different courts, and residential time in a custody order does not authorize contact the criminal order forbids. Violating an order entered under chapter 9.94A or 10.99 is charged under RCW 7.105.450, which also covers civil protection orders. The family court also weighs the conviction on its own terms. RCW 26.09.191(4)(a) requires limits on residential time for a parent with a history of domestic violence.
The contrast with civil protection orders is worth knowing. When a civil order restrains a respondent from contacting their own minor children, RCW 7.105.315(2)(a) limits that restraint to a fixed period of no more than one year, with renewal possible. The criminal order in Mitchell would have run five times that long.
The record made at sentencing is where alternatives get preserved. A defense attorney can ask the court to consider supervised visits, letters screened by a third party, contact limited to what a family court later orders, or a shorter term. A request that was made and ignored gives an appellate court something to review.
Questions About a No-Contact Order With Children
Does the Judge Always Have to Explain the Order on the Record?
Not always. Under Reedy, a sentencing court may skip a detailed explanation when the record is full of evidence showing the order is necessary. The judge still has to consider the right to parent. In Mitchell, the court never mentioned it at all.
Did the Father in Mitchell Get Contact With His Daughters Back?
No, not yet. The appellate court sent the order back for the trial court to weigh his right to parent against the children's welfare. The judge can reach the same result after doing that analysis.
Can a Parenting Plan Override a Criminal No-Contact Order?
No, a parenting plan that grants residential time does not excuse contact a criminal order prohibits. The way to change a criminal order's terms is through the criminal court that entered it.
Talk to a Seattle Domestic Violence Defense Attorney About Your Children
An order entered at sentencing can shape a parent's relationship with their children for years, and the time to argue for less restrictive terms is before the judge rules. Blair Kim Moeller, PLLC defends parents charged with domestic violence offenses in Seattle, Bellevue, and throughout King, Pierce, and Snohomish Counties, and Mark Blair works with our family law attorneys when a criminal case and a custody case overlap. Call us at (206) 622-6562 or schedule a consultation online to go through your situation with one of our attorneys.